The new disclosure framework and also the general meaning of which verse are not, but not, on the matter of matrimony to help you non-Muslims. This new ancient interpretation claims that verse is shown whenever several polytheist guys out of Quraish required their sisters to-be right back, Oum Kelthoum and you may Bint Aqabah, once they had converted to Islam and you will moved to Medina when you look at the acquisition to join the newest Muslim people.
It general idea isn’t necessarily real additionally the “strength” or perhaps the “weakness” of your religious belief is not of the intercourse however, alternatively toward person’s personality and you can character
It’s well worth reminding that the Prophet closed during the time an agreement named Al-Hudaybya Pact with the opposing tribe away from Quraish to cease brand new conflict to possess a decade. It agreement specified, yet others, that people Quraychit girl that would join the Prophet inside Medina with no consent of this lady legal tutor is sent back in order to Mecca.
Oum Kelthoum, who had been the only one to alter so you’re able to Islam within her members of the family, and you will just who fled in one of the very hostile environments, begged the brand new Prophet not to repatriate the lady to the girl tribe so just like the never to getting unsealed again on the unfair treatment.
The brand new verse previously mentioned was then found to eliminate this new extradition of females which transformed into Islam and steer clear of the vengeance of its respective families. Therefore, the latest Prophet refused to send right back brand new exiled girls with the foes, as the contract was maintained for men.
The explanation of one’s verse aforementioned shows that it will maybe not handle in any way the wedding to non-Muslims, however, is actually as an alternative revealed to satisfy specific proper criteria from protecting ladies who converted to Islam resistant to the have a tendency to of its family and just who voluntarily wanted the new Prophet’s shelter.
Brand new contradiction that people high light in these ancient perceptions inquiries brand new proven fact that based on such scholars, Muslim women can be prohibited so you can get married “disbelievers” in addition to Christian and Jewish men, when you’re to your matter of Muslim men, Religious and you can Jewish women can be thought to be believers. How do we believe, in the same Christian or Jewish area, you to definitely men are disbelievers if you are lady of the identical organizations try believers?
In the absence of one facts one warrants the latest ban out-of the wedding regarding Muslim women to the followers from most other monotheistic religions, the contemporary students justify the attitudes because of the “the pure weakness” from Muslim women who could go astray underneath the “bad” influence of its Religious otherwise Jewish husbands. But the Muslim man can control his Religious otherwise Jewish wife and manage his kid’s and you can individual trust.
The Qur’anic verse, tackling the wedding from Muslim men or women in order to believers out of almost every other religions, lay specific guidelines having fun with a keen egalitarian code
Indeed, the latest argument is not convincing as if brand new told you verse prohibits the wedding ranging from a great Muslim girl and you will an excellent Christian otherwise Jewish guy since it is unanimously interpreted now, thus instance marriage is also taboo to the Muslim son. Nevertheless, centered on various Qur’anic verses additionally the Islamic integrity, Christians and you can Jews are considered interracialpeoplemeet dobrze unanimously once the believers owned by religions found because of the Allah whatever the established variations in regards to the newest dogma together with theological viewpoints.
This means that, the research with the verse signifies that the new Qur’an prohibits the brand new relationships regarding both Muslim individuals to polytheists.
But it is worth discussing one to scholars concur unanimously to the ban of the wedding from a good Muslim lady to help you a good Jewish or Religious, when you’re no an element of the Qur’an offers up like prohibition you to warrants that it discrimination.